Hi Kim!
This letter is long overdue. My
family and I are so very grateful to you and your network of friends.
Please share this letter with them.
I cannot even count the number of times I have
reminded my boys how fortunate we are to have had the support
of so many friends, family, strangers and new friends!
We are surrounded by reminders of the generosity that was
bestowed upon us, from the towels we use, dishes we eat from or
beds and linens we sleep on.
It has been an eventful year and I would like
to take this opportunity to update you on what has happened.
The boys’ were ordered to be returned home to me on September
15, 2003. Shortly thereafter, their father
contacted the police and Children’s Aid Society with allegations
that I was abusing the children. The CAS immediately
recognized the frivolous nature of the allegations and were very
supportive of me. They continue to be involved
as they recognize the abusive nature of the father and to support
me as he continues to make frivolous allegations against me.
Their father refused to allow the boys to attend
counselling and threatened to sue the school board if they allowed
any social workers to speak with the children. Custody
had not been ordered at this point so as he refused counselling
the children could not receive it. Meanwhile
he continued to make allegations of abuse against me so I challenged
him to let the children attend the counselling to deal with the
abuse that he claimed that I subjected them to. He
continued to refuse this.
We had several court appearances throughout the
process. The family court judges readily recognized
the father’s abusive nature and it was progressing well.
The Office of the Children’s Lawyer did a three-month investigation
recommending sole custody to the mother, mental health therapy
to the father and suggesting that thought should be given to supervised
access for the father. The settlement court
judge advised that if she were the trial judge she would recommend
sole custody to the mother and supervised access by the father.
I could not have hoped for better and went into the final
trial with optimism.
Things took a terrible turn as we had a criminal
judge for the final trial. The judge appeared
to buy the father’s performance as he gave testimony alleging
abuse and neglect on my part. At the end of
the first day of trial, hearing only the father’s testimony, the
judge proclaimed that he was “an extraordinary father” and he
was going to get more access to the children and half of my house.
The father was caught in a number of his lies on the second
day of trial. We settled with sole custody
of the children to me before the judge had an opportunity to hear
testimony refuting the father’s story and proving his perjury.
The judge never did hear evidence of his lies so the father
was left in a position of credibility and the judge ordered that
he get half of my home.
The judge refused to address the property issue
as we had a previous judge make an interim order on this issue.
The previous judge had made an order clearly stating that
it was only an interim order to provide items to care for the
children until we went to trial. The order
also stated that the final trial judge should deal with this but
that did not happen. The property that was
ordered to be returned was the fridge, stove and freezer then
minimal items such as spices, kitchen items, pillows, games, etc.
The father has failed to return my property despite the
fact that there have now been four court orders to do so.
Each court order has resulted in my entitlement to my property
diminishing with each subsequent order.
We had to return to court after the trial because
the father refused to return my property and pay daycare.
We appeared before the same trial judge who actually chastised
me for returning the matter to court and further reduced
the court order so that there are now less than a dozen items
that he has to return and his daycare responsibility was further
reduced in half and limited to three months. In
July 2004, he attempted to return property that he stole from
his current landlord. His direction to the
movers was that I had to accept the delivery in its entirety or
everything had to be returned to his residence. I
obviously could not accept stolen property so I was not allowed
to keep anything. To date, he has still failed
to return my property.
My eldest has been attending counselling for Children
Who Have Witnessed Violence and Abuse since November 2004 and
it is going well. My middle son will attend
the next group in the Winter/Spring session but he is doing extremely
well. It’s primarily my eldest who has suffered
the brunt of the abuse and has been having behaviour issues.
My youngest son is just three so has experienced little
affect and is a pure joy.
The boys now, although reluctantly, attend church
with me every weekend that they are with me. The
two older boys are scheduled to receive their sacraments of First
Communion and Confirmation in the Spring. My
middle one is looking forward to this while the eldest is still
rebelling. If he’s not ready then this will
simply have to wait.
As for me, my employment was based in Toronto
so I was forced to resign from my position as of Nov 2003.
As an HR professional, the bilingualism issue continued
to be a barrier to employment throughout most of the year.
I was fortunate to secure a 6-week contract with DND in
September 2004 which has been extended until April 2005.
I am hopeful that the experience will eventually lead to
another opportunity.
I always believe that things happen for a reason.
Admittedly, I struggle to understand the reason behind
the outcome of my trial. I focus on the fact
that the most important aspect of the trial was custody and I
have sole custody and primary residence of the children.
They spend one night a week and every second weekend with
their father. The rest of the trial was money
and stuff and that’s not what’s important in life.
While it has certainly been a challenging year,
it has been overshadowed with the wonderful blessings that we
have received. We have been so very fortunate
to have received the support and generosity of so many wonderful
people. I am often asked how I have stayed
so positive during such challenging times. My
response is always that I recognize that there has been only one
source of bad and so very many sources of good. I
have drawn enormous strength from the support, kindness, warmth
and generosity of family, friends and strangers. I
believe that we choose our attitude and I choose to let the goodness
overshadow all else. Focusing on our blessings
and recognizing all of our good fortune has made this a truly
blessed year.
My home is filled with love and furnished with
the generosity of so many. I am thankful for
the many blessings that we have. I believe
that my children do recognize how fortunate we are that so many
people reached out to help us. I will be eternally
grateful for your generosity and support and it will take a lifetime
to pay it forward.
My best wishes to all of you and your families
during the Christmas holidays and throughout the New Year.
I hope you recognize the enormous difference you have made
in our lives. Although a mere thank you cannot
even begin to express my gratitude, I thank you with all my heart!
Love,
Lise and the boys |